New York-Style Pizza in Southern Shores
If you're searching for great pizza on the Outer Banks, look no further than Cosmo's Pizzeria at The Marketplace in Southern Shores!
Cosmo’s Pizzeria has been serving award winning “New York” style pizza to Outer Banks locals and visitors since 1995. Recognized as a local favorite, Cosmo’s only uses the finest ingredients to prepare the freshest pizza, tastiest pasta dishes and mouth-watering subs on the northern beaches.
Voted 2024 and 2025 Bronze Winner for the BEST PIZZA in the Reader's Choice BEST of the OBX contest!
Also Serving:
Strombolis
Calzones
Meatballs
Toasted Subs
Chicken Parmesan
Cannolis
Rigatoni Penne
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Cheesesteaks
Gluten-Free Pasta
Cosmo’s beer list includes a selection of both domestics and imports, and wine is available by the bottle or glass. We also have a selection of fountain sodas and bottled drinks. And if you have a sweet tooth, be sure to try a famous cannoli for dessert!
Grab your crew and satisfy your Outer Banks pizza craving at Cosmo's Pizzeria in Southern Shores, open year-round!
THANK YOU for Voting Us a Winner in the BEST OF OBX Contest!
2024-2026 WINNER
Best Pizza
July 3, 2026
Join us Friday, July 3rd, 2026 for the SUN Realty Freedom 5k/1 Mile - 7:30 AM and Little Sparkler 1/4 Mile Fun Run - 8:10 AM!
Avid Outer Banks Surfers and sightseers alike are familiar with Old Lighthouse Beach, a stretch of sand in the heart of Buxton that was once the sight of the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse. Convenient and renowned for its good shelling and great waves...
Anyone with a fascination of history and America's European roots will love a day exploring the Elizabeth II, a historic 16th century sailing vessel that is docked along the borders of the Roanoke Island Festival Park. This ship can be admired by...
Always Included, complimentary linens and made beds! Flooring and fixture upgrades planned for 2026. Let this bright and beachy home Quench your thirst for everything the OBX has to offer. Sea...
- Nags Head
- 4 Bedrooms
- 4 Bathrooms
